Tim's Tumblr

Posts tagged politics

0 notes &

Kettle tactics risk Hillsborough-style tragedy – doctor | UK news | The Observer

Protesters “kettled” by police on Westminster Bridge had to be treated for symptoms of severe crushing and for head injuries. A doctor who was there warns that use of the tactic could lead to actual deaths similar to those at Hillsborough in the 1980s when football fans were crushed to death.

Filed under politics uk politics kettling police Metropolitan Police human rights safety crowds crowd control Westminster Bridge students links

Notes &

Ministers accused of 'burying' damning report on impact of benefits cuts | Society | The Observer

This reminds me of when the Thatcher goverment ignored warnings that their policies would create youth homelessness in the 1980s, and within a fortnight of said policies being implemented, I started regularly seeing young people begging in central Manchester. Before that, the only homeless people I came across appeared to be middle-aged alcoholics.

Filed under links politics uk politics cuts homelessness Conservatives Tories housing benefit

4 notes &

Radical thought

I think it would be really good if the BBC, when choosing people to comment about a particular news issue, would ask themselves “In what way is this person qualified to give an informed opinion on the subject?” Normally they just pick two people with extreme and opposite opinions, and maybe a political journalist.

Example: the government are proposing measuring national levels of happiness. If done properly, this would clearly be an exercise in psychology, mental health, and social research. Yet when it was discussed on the radio, not one psychologist, social scientist, mental health worker or similar was interviewed. Not even a happiness researcher (such people exist!) Not one person who could say whether such an approach could give meaningful or useful information or whether it was just a fantasy policy. Merely some politicians from opposite ends of the spectrum, and a journalist or two.

Why not have comments on a subject from people who actually understand the subject? And why present people who have no reason to know what they’re talking about as though they were somehow qualified?

Filed under commenters rationality irrationality politics ignorance BBC politicians politics juournalists happiness social science psychology mental health interviews media grumble